Saturday, July 9, 2011

Eloy a Decade in Space!


I've absolutely fallen in love with Eloy over the past few months! I remember seeing this band around all the time when I first started getting into 70s Prog 10 years ago. Not sure why, but I never really investigated them. Perhaps the breadth of their discography was intimidating and didn't really know where to start. And their name was kind of goofy, and it wasn't till recently that I discovered it was an ode to the race of people known as the 'Eloi' in HG Wells "The Time Machine." When I did get around to sampling them I don't think they hit me the same way bands like Gentle Giant and Magma were then so I pretty much ignored them since. As of late I've been wanting to immerse myself in a new 70s Prog band with a vast discography that I haven't touched on yet (considering there's always something new to discover in 70s Prog.) The problem with this is a number of great 70s Prog bands only had one or a very few albums. And the bands who had longer careers, either I'm already familiar with, or with many Prog bands who started strong in the late 60s/early 70s, by the time they got to the late 70s and definitely into the 80s, they started to stink pretty bad. What appealed to me about Eloy right off the bat, I was really wanting something drenched in keyboards, with lots of swirling spacey/fantasy sounds, but also where the keys don't completely dominate and play a complimentary and harmonious role along side the guitars. I absolutely adore primitive and early synthesizer sounds, there is something very cerebral about it all and it takes me back to the mythical era of the late 60s and 70s which is era of music I wish I would have been around for and experienced first hand. Well, I was born in the early 70s, but I was a baby then, and didn't really experience this stuff properly. Also seeing movies like the animated LOTR and The Hobbit as well as Fantastic Planet, Watership Down, NausicaƤ, etc at an early age has always weighed heavy on my mind as non-musical inspirations on my taste in music, since a lot of this stuff went hand n hand with the musics I've always liked (Metal, Prog, etc.) So listening to a band like Eloy it brings to mind spacey images of winged warriors armed with both lasers and swords going off to battle some cosmic evil overlord in a fantasy realm of vast colors and psychedelic cheese. Hey that kind of sounds like Flash Gordon! We'll I'm no stranger to that fantastic movie, and there were some great synthesizer dominated anthems on the soundtrack done by Queen which I can also attest to being an early musical influence of my youth. Like Flash Gordon and it's memorable soundtrack, Eloy is histrionic and a little cheesy as well but that's part of the fun and what I like about them! Despite that, they were fantastic musicians that created some truly otherworldly and transcendent music without any shame. The first album I got from them was "Ocean" as it seems to be generally thought of as their best album. Well it's definitely awash in keyboards and epic fantastical imagery. The vocals (Frank Bornemann) actually threw me off a bit as they are heavily German accented English sung lyrics, but I've always had a thing for unusual vocals so they grew on me quickly. Sometimes they sound like a speak/sing style as he narrates the oceanic fairy tales. The album was great, but only had 4 long songs. I wanted more! So the next purchase was the previous album "Dawn." Which I was totally blown away by! After that I started to read reviews on the Prog archives on their other albums as well as listening to songs from various albums on youtube. With that I came to the conclusion that Eloy indeed had more great albums than just a few. So over the course of a few weeks I ended up getting all the rest of their albums from 73 to 82, which you see blow. I've been immersing myself in these albums over the past few months and it almost seems to be all I've been listening too. It's been fun hearing how this band progressed from the Hammond organ, jammy, Psychedelic Hardrock of their first few albums and slowing morphing into the spacey. symphonic juggernaut that they became in the late 70s and beyond.


This is actually their 2nd album, and I don't have their s/t debut album which seems to be currently OOP. The S/T is very much gravelly Bluesy Hardrock album (or early Heavy Metal), with the occasional "weird" Krautrock and psychedelic moments, lots of jammy parts, bluesy long winded solos, the works.... strangely no keys or organ present on this album, or very little. It's a beginning but doesn't excite me the way the rest of their albums do.
The 2nd album, Inside, they take their first step outside of the stratosphere. It's none more apparent then the first side long anthem "Land of No Body" with the great use of the Hammond organ as well as plenty of adventurous variety throughout the song which moves you higher and higher to the 3rd climactic act. This album still retains some of that Hardrock grit from the first album, but you can tell that they wanted to explore further in terms of sound and timbre.




Floating sees the band making even greater use of the Hammond organ as well as the first inclusion of other keyboards. There seems to be even more of a rocking energy to this album than the previous. Songs like "Castle In The Air" and the "The Light From Deep Darkness" are both highlights of the album, which are driving, melodic and adventurous with lots of parts and you can also hear the fantastical Epic side of Eloy starting to creeping in with these 2 songs. Great space rock here rivaling their contemporaries at the time Hawkwind. Frank Bornemann trademarked accented vocals seems to becoming more apparent on this album, oddly enough.
With Power and the Passion the band takes on its first concept album about time travel, and by this time you can safely say they are a full blown Progressive Rock band. This album, on a whole seems to be a bit more mellow then their previous works. They seem to concentrate more on the texture and floating atmosphere created by the organ, keyboards, moog and guitars. The vocals even seem to be a bit quieter for some reason. The only problem I have with this album is its non-imposing nature, sometimes the songs go by without you even noticing them. Not something to rock out in the car, but more for relaxing while lying in bed.



/>

These 3 albums are their highpoint IMO.
Right off the bat you'll notice a difference in production with Dawn. As its louder, clearer, and more powerful sounding from the previous album. The song writing on this album is refined and the structures are intricate well layered and the most sophisticated they've ever been thus far. The guitar is only up front some of the time, but for the most part shares the stage in perfect harmony with the rest of the instruments for the sake of atmosphere. There is string section added, as well as plenty of keys and synths making this a very dense and ambitious album. I think this is Eloy coming into their own and finally carving out their own musical language in the vast universe and Progressive Rock.
Ocean is an even grander attempt and generally thought of as their masterpiece. I think I prefer Dawn (as well as Silent Cries) just a bit more only because there seems to be more variety and tempo shifts present. Ocean is brilliant in its own right though and I can understand why its lauded as their best. Songs are slow to build but beautiful to behold, unveiling 4 ambient, monolithic songs..., each are like gods drifting slowly across the sky in all their titanic majesty! Probably best listened to without any other distractions so you can absorb all the detail and loose yourself in the grandiose nature of this album.
Silent Cries and Mighty Echoes follows the lofty symphonic path of the previous 2 although it definitely has some qualities that keeps it distinct from the rest.
This album has a slightly more 'modern' production of the late 70s, but still very 70s sounding. Lots of extravagant keys and synths drenching the songs in surreal beauty. And this time around they even have some deliberate hooks. Songs like "Master of Sensation" and "Pilot to Paradise" seem to construct somewhat pop structured songs with verse and chorus, combined with the spacey Prog style in which they mastered on the previous 2 albums. These songs are still very long and instrument driven so I would only say they flirted a bit with pop structures on this album, in which I think it came as a benefit as the songs have a memorable quality all the while still epic and complex. The song "The Apocalypse" is the longest sprawling song on this album, so if you didn't quite get enough of those giant tunes off of Ocean, you got one here to satisfy the pallet.



Now this album stands unique in all their catalog. You can already see a bit of a shift in style on Silent Cries, but Colours is very much a crossover from their Epic Prog into the shorter tighter style of songs they continued to write on their next 2 albums. Colour is the last album in which they still use an analog production keeping it grounded in the warmth of 70s tones. The late 70s was definitely a tumultuous time in regard to the trends in Popular music and a lot of Prog bands who had some great and creative albums during the early/mid 70s were left floundering in the winds of change. A band like Eloy was never going to find the success of a Prog band going Pop the way Genesis did, nor do I think they had the right frame of mind to create something truly progressive and groudbreaking as This Heat or Art Bears. So it would seem like they were heading for something more terse and accessible than ever before with Colours. Although they didn't go Pop, at least not on this album, they still retain some incredibly complex musical arrangements and I might even say it's the most rhythmically dense album of their career. On the surface one might think the album is simpler than their previous efforts but that's definitely not the case as Colours is very involved with a lot syncopation going on and can even be described as a bit funky at times. Not an easy album to wrap your head around though, there's a lot of melodic counterpoint and polyrhythmic passages to keep your mind busy. A challenging album that will guarantee much reward upon repeated listens. The spacey and fantastical trademarks and imagery are still in place as well making this very much distinctly an 'Eloy' album.




Planets
and Time to Turn
These 2 albums definitely have the stink of the 80s on them. The production and keyboards are all digital now, and there's a bit of an AOR flavor as well. But you know?... I still really like these albums! And for my money these are both very worthy Eloy albums never betraying or scoffing at anything they've ever been about in the past. Songs once again, are still spacey and fantastical, still plenty of cosmic swirling synths, they don't go for more 'mature' lyrical content and keep everything grounded in fantasy and Scifi themes they've always been comfortable with. The synths are 'colder' and more sterile sounding which was a common trend at the time but to me that brings a new robotic and somewhat technical atmosphere which compliments Eloy's extraterrestrial style of Space Rock quite well. With that said, there might have been a bit of a stab at mainstream success by the some of the more simplified and hooky structures present here and I wouldn't say these are prefect albums by any means, but they are still incredibly enjoyable. Even if you don't like some of the Poppier elements found within these 2 albums, there are still songs like "End of an Odyssey" which is a slow building Epic hearkening back to the days of Ocean. And not to mention many other songs which clock in over the 6 min mark, which all display great complex structuring with plenty of variety and great key and guitar work.

And that's about as far as I went with Eloy. The band continued beyond this point but reading reviews on the albums that go deeper into the 80s and 90s the reviews seem to be mixed, but generally in the negative. I'll take the majorities word for it. I may check into the supposed 'back to form' albums "The Tides Return Forever" and "Ocean 2" somewhere down the line, but I'm pretty satisfied with the 9 albums I have now.

A Thought on A Feast for Crows



I find the negative flack this book has gotten to be unfounded and naive. Made by those who think everything should follow a linear path and operating under the faulty assumption that this series will end in some glorious conclusion that ties everything together. I have no such expectation. As we have already experienced throughout 'A Song of Ice and Fire' thus far is that nothing is safe and nothing stays the same. Personally I feel this book is as good as any of the others in the series, it's an intricate bridge between the first and second half of this saga and I personally can't wait for the second half to begin! "A Feast for Crows" is exactly what it states in the title: a fractured war torn country with the remaining powers-that-be picking through the carnage struggling to put itself back together again, amidst corruption, conspiracies and the constant grab for power amongst its players. We are finally being introduced to the Bishops and Rooks in this giant game of Chess. I know some people want to just focus on pawns, knights, and kings, but I would like to see how the whole game is played. I also like the focus on the feminine in this book. I think it helps set the table for Dany's return. Some have complained that Martin is misogynist in his approach to female characters. I don't agree at all. I think the gender rolls in this book are deeply rooted in the medieval histories that Martin draws upon. With that in mind I see the female characters as women struggling within the confines of those norms. I love the parallels between Sansa's emergence into "the game" and Cersei's fall from power. Cersei has always been one of the most interesting characters in the series and was glad to see her finally introduced as a POV character. Martin once again takes things deeper and makes her more ambiguous by taking us into the psychology and early childhood experiences of her flawed character. I also like the parallels between the Arya and Brienne stories. Another motif that seems to pop up repeatedly is that every commoner is talking about how they have some royal blood in them. I don't recall this being as central in the prior books and it seems to me that this reflects the beginning of a change in mindset as more and more common people start to hint that they might be just as good as anyone else. The Feudal system of Westeros still looks an awful lot like slavery at times and I can't wait to see how the entrance of the Free Folk and Dany's ideas about ruling start to impact the seven kingdoms and their fracturing houses. Some people bitch about all the random new POV characters and more seem to complain how he left out 3 of the most central characters (namely Tyrion, Dany and Jon Show.) It seems to me that this complaint is premature until the series is complete. We are only at a bridge section now. Minor characters in the first book are major characters in the third book and some characters disappear in the first book only to pop up again in the third. With this in mind I will assume that these 'filler' characters and the information revealed in their chapters is relevant to later parts of the story. I also hope these whiners didn't miss that several MAIN (Sansa/Arya) characters have changed chapter titles to reflect a change in their own self-concept. If they missed the "Alayne" chapters or "Cat of the Canals" then they missed out on important developments regarding several of the core characters in the book. I've always felt that THEE central character in 'A Song of Ice and Fire' is the world that Martin has created, not one individual (Same could be said for Tolkien's LOTR.) The great houses are turning against each other and power becomes more and more fractured amidst a spiritual renaissance. The emerging powers are these religious leaders but their competing faiths are clearly in moral conflict with one another. And let us not forget the rational/scientific side reflected by the Maesters. Few of them seem to respect or acknowledge the re-emergence of magic. I was so excited to finally get to know Oldtown and gain some insight into the Maesters and how they fit into the game as well.

Like many I'll be starting 'A Dance with Dragons' very soon, and it will be interesting to see how it reflects against this book... and for some reason I have a feeling that there will be plenty of complainers about that one as well. We'll have to see but it's nice to gather some thoughts on 'A Feast for Crows' at the cusp of ADWD so I can personally have this, at this date to look back on when I'm done reading book 5 of 'A Song of Ice and Fire.'

...a few more of my thoughts collected on AFFC that I posted on message board....

I can't see how anyone could have been disappointed with AFFC, as there's so much going on here for anyone to become bored with the story: finally baring witness to Cersei's flawed character, her fall from grace as well a making key mistakes that lead to that fall (militarizing the church, pissing on Kevan, her growing paranoia, etc), Jamie and his gradual change of heart, he actually seems to "mature" and see things in a new light during this post-handloss version of Jamie, not to mention him finally seeing Cersei as the flawed person as she's always been. You get more inside on Oldtown and the Maesters, Doran and Arianne Martell and the Sand Snakes (who I think are fucking awesome! I can't wait to see how these sly and beautiful women start bringing down the powers that be from the inside and out.) And of course a true inside to The Greyjoy's and the Drowned God, with Aeron and the Kingsmoot, Euron and the Horn, and of course Victarion who totally fucking Slays in his Reaver chapter.

There are 2 kinds of people who read this book. Those who go in expecting everything to tie up in the end in a nice pretty little bow, they don't want to put too much effort in memorizing much beyond the Stark children and their revenge, and Dany as some sort of flawless super hero thats going to come back to Westeros save all, and every time the story opens up beyond that delving further into complication and detail it frustrates them and they blame GRRM for not doing what they want.

Then there are those like us, who know you have to give and invest time and brain power in order to get the full potential out of this story. There comes a point in the story where you really need to start committing the details to memory, towns, castles, map locations, names, houses, histories and so forth. Its not just about the present and whats to come in the future but also the past and how it will all eventually tie together. I believe you get even more from re-reading the entire series (or at least listening to the audio while you work, like I do), or at least going back and re-reading certain parts in order to get some of the finer details down pat. . This shit just comes alive in your mind like no other. Tolkien's world was just as rich, but not as much text nor nearly as many players (which is saying quite a lot considering the histories of Beleriand and Middle-Earth still had an above average amount of named characters and players in them.) I don't even think any of the renowned Russian classics with all their character's can come close to the shear vastness created by GRRM. I've read War and Peace and it seems small in comparison. It boils down to this and a question I would pose to anyone wanting to start the series - my GF as well as coworker has started reading and what I ask is - how far are you willing to go? and how much are you willing to give in order to get the most out of these novels?